Friday, July 31, 2015
Brokeback Mountain Reconsidered
Annie
Proulx has written a short story about a love affair between a pair
of cowboys in Wyoming where gay boys get beaten to death. Polite
society has tried to avoid dealing with the love that dare not say
its name for centuries. What do we think was the service provided by
cabin boys and midshipman on 5-year ocean voyages. What was the
relationship between Charles Darwin and his sea captain friend on the
Beagle. That between Lewis and Clark on their trip across America.
What went on between pubescent Cowboys during those long cattle
drives. As couples have demonstrated for centuries not all
relationships are based on sex.
It
is interesting that Jack Twist initiated this coupling but it is
Ennis Del Mar who is the top in this relationship. A man of few words
Ennis is the realist while Jack is the dreamer. Hetero marriage by
gay men for years has been a common cover-up for activities that
could land one in jail or worse. Indiscreet behaviour could ruin
reputations and even get you killed. It is a terrible irony that the
AIDS epidemic occurred shortly after gay liberation brought gays out
of the closet.
Small
comfort for this couple who confined their couplings to the remote
wilderness. Denial and self-loathing are an all-too common
consequence. Ennis drifts from one dead-end job to another his wife
divorcing him; Jack in high-risk behaviours with both sexes that
eventually gets him killed.